Keep It or Lose It? The Pros and Cons of Root Canals and Extractions

October 16, 2026

Dentist showing patient X-ray while recommending treatment

A toothache is bad enough, but hearing the words “root canal or extraction?” can really add stress on top. In the moment, it can be difficult to decide, especially when you’re in pain. So, which treatment should you choose? Dentists tend to try to save your natural tooth when they can, but sometimes extraction is best for your oral health. Keep reading to weigh the pros and cons of each so you can make an informed decision.

Why Dentists Want You To Keep Your Natural Teeth

Your natural teeth are incredibly strong and resilient if you take care of them. They help you chew, smile, keep your other teeth in their proper places, and strengthen your jawbone. Removing a tooth creates an imbalance in the structure of your mouth and can make you feel self-conscious. This is why dentists tend to always try to save your natural teeth whenever possible.

What Does a Root Canal Offer?

Root canals remove infected pulp (the innermost part of the tooth with the nerve endings) and seal it off from infection. While this cuts off the blood supply to the tooth, it allows you to continue using it after it’s topped with a crown. That means the roots stay intact and continue to benefit your smile for many years.

When Is a Root Canal the Best Choice?

Root canals are a good choice if your tooth is severely decayed or damaged, but salvageable. Your dentist can make that determination after an exam and can usually perform the procedure in a single appointment.

What Does Extraction Offer?

Extraction is quicker and less costly at first, so many patients choose this procedure, especially when they’re in pain. However, it leaves a gap, and without a replacement, nearby teeth can drift into the space. This can be corrected with an implant, bridge, or denture, but this adds time and expense, making it more expensive in the long term.

When Is Extraction the Better Choice?

Some teeth can’t be saved. When there’s a severe fracture, a crack below your gumline, too little healthy tooth left, or jawbone destroyed by gum disease, a root canal may not be enough. In those cases, extraction and replacement is often the best way forward.

Root canals and extractions can both benefit your oral health in different situations. If you’re not sure which would be best, just give your dentist a call. They’ll examine your teeth, take X-rays, and give you their recommendation. Whenever it’s possible, the best tooth is usually the one you were born with, and a root canal can help you keep it.

About the Practice

At Windermere Dentistry, our team offers root canal treatment to relieve tooth pain and help you keep your natural tooth. When a tooth can’t be saved, we also provide extractions and replacement options like implants and dentures. Feeling anxious about your upcoming procedure? Nitrous oxide and oral conscious sedation are available to help you relax and get the care you need. Call (407) 909-1099 to schedule your visit and find the right path for your tooth.